|
Notes
on the Hornady 366 auto shotshell Part III: poor crimp solutions, 410 skeet reloading Part
I:
Introduction, mounting set-up, powder/shot
bushings
discussion for Part
II:
General problem
solutions/tool
adjustments for best results. Part
III:
Some reasons and solutions for poor
quality crimp results. Includes Part
IV: On
changing dies to a different gauge, setting up a
new die head or
just Part VI: Some thoughts on the buying of a used 366. Also includes the essential tool and recommended spare parts lists. Index: DisclaimerSpecial section on 410 bore skeet reloading This
article
is mainly written for those who
have owned 366's
for while and are interested in possibly picking up some tips,
or otherwise experienced loaders looking for information
on the Hornady 366 auto shotshell
reloading press. Use of the
information is at your own risk. These
notes come from nearly 40 years
working
with the
Pacific/Hornady 366 reloading tool; others
will have had different
experiences. If you are not an experienced reloader, please,
please,
please buy
the several excellent books that are on the market
and become intimately familiar with the process and
the very necessary safety
procedures. Reading the MSDS statements available on the
various manufacturer's websites provides valuable
information as well as the powder recipe booklets forewords. These
booklets are available either by download or by mail at no charge to
the requester. Many of those sites offer how-to-reload information as
well. Always follow exactly the loading recipes
supplied by the
propellant manufacturers. Reloading is not a place for short-cuts and
sloppy guesswork.
And
obviously, you cannot safely reload
with best quality when
you
are tired, in a hurry, or otherwise not able
give
your full and proper
attention to the job. Tips On making perfect shotshell crimps:
For
perfect, flat crimps, the components chosen must have a certain
height. The components here
come to about 19/32"//12 mm from the top of the shot to the hull mouth
for the
following crimps. Note the (24 grams of) shot does not overflow the top
of
the
one-ounce Claybuster CB1100-12 wad. Case wall crushing is also
eliminated and
crimps
appear more consistently uniform as a result of
this wad choice.
pre-fold
will lead to a side case mouth bulge giving chambering problems
(maximum cartridge diameter is 0.797, per the Lyman Reloading
Handbook). Note: if you have an older black-finished
final crimp die, the newer 12 (and 20) gauge natural-finished crimp die
body dimensions
have been changed to improve crimp results. Hornady offers a complete
crimper assembly. No number is listed in the parts list, but the nice
ladies at the Hornady parts order desk will have it for you. Three results showing a nice flat crimp. And no case wall crushing (tire rim around the middle).
Speaking of hull wall crushing (example, right), I'll go with the assumption this is occurring in the final crimp station (it can happen in the Taper-Loc and pre-fold station as well if they are adjusted too low). Be sure the final crimp station is set per the Hornady manual. Note that sometimes increasing the number of threads exposed more than the manual suggests above the locking ring helps. If so, this is a pretty straight-forward fix. The basic problem is simply too much stuff in the case. Other than the "tire rim" around the middle, further proof is usually shown by a convex crimp. Reifenhauser case plastic is relatively weak, so when you adjust for the proper crimp depth when the component length is too much for the case, the result is that the case can buckle, creating the tire rim. Often,
acceptable results can still be achieved by backing off a bit on
the final crimp plunger for a slightly shallower crimp. Usually,
the easiest long-term
solution is to use a shorter wad (A simple
alternative could
be to jack
up the wad pressure to crush the wad
shorter. Crimps may not be as consistent.).
If you're loading 24 grams, then use the 28 gram wad. Or see
the wad
list to select a slightly
shorter
24 gram wad. An example might going from a Winchester WW12L to
Claybuster
CB1100-12 to a WW12SL, or
from a
B&P
T2 wad to the Gualandi
REX or even the SPARX, depending on the case type.
This is a
minimal amount of pre-fold in this B&P case. In general,
for most plastics, this
small amount won't work with an unacceptable crimp resulting, but it
varies depending
on case plastic type and construction (see next section). It's safest
to go with the 1/4" prefold as a standard. A bit less
pre-fold than the standard 1/4" is useful with the longer component
combinations to achieve a flat crimp, but there is little room for
error: defective crimps tend to start showing up in a hurry.
Note flatness, but hole in center of crimp, left two shells because of too little pre-fold. (Center shell is the shell shown above.) Perfect crimp on the right hand shell after final pre-fold increase tweak. It's sensitive at this point: adjust a quarter turn at a time. Also with insufficient pre-fold, you can experience significant operating handle resistance as the crimp plunger hits the top of the case mouth, crushing same until the plastic folds over. In addition to the high resistance until the plastic folds, the crimps have a unique look:
Left, example result of crushing the case mouth in the crimping station. Right, how the crimp should look with proper pre-fold. Note clean, sharp center. A caution on setting Reifenhauser pre-fold:
Using pre-fold to the point where the crimp line bulges out sometimes results in the above - type case indentations. These sometimes are bad enough to cause chambering difficulties. The older Scot Powder Solo1000 powder manual (eighth edition) had a picture like this with the admonition not to shoot them. No further explanation was offered. . .
On another note, if you start observing off-center/bad crimps, remove and check the prefold die. The latest incarnation of this die uses high, thin ridges. While this definitely improves crimp quality over the old triangular shape, mechanically the ridges are weaker; they can and do break. As you can see below:
Yep , they DO break. Note the broken ridges to the left and right.
Note both crimps are off center with one or more badly formed sections. One or two could be a fluke; several, time to check the pre-fold die for damage. Does case length matter? Results of pre-fold set for 70 mm hulls, then 68 mm hulls loaded:
366 set for Remington STS 70 mm hulls. Left, 70 mm hull prefold 1/4"//6.3mm. Right hull 68 mm, or 3/32"//2 mm shorter. Note the prefold width is considerably wider. And the crimping results? See below:
Consequences of a mal-formed prefold:
Shell that came out of the pre-fold die in disaster shape
Another
example
of results from an improper pre-fold. Note the BB's ready to
slip out and float around your
shooting
vest pocket.
Left: An example of a hull likely to badly pre-fold. Note the nearly non-existent crimp lines on the right side of the hull. Often a potential bad pre-fold occurs with empties that come from factory shells that were loaded to high velocities, as the 1300'/s 1 1/8 oz (32 gram) Sporting Clays loads by Remington and Winchester. The handicaps are also somewhat liable. If this problem is spotted before running through the 366, a quick hit (right photo) with a spare prefold die by hand can insure a good crimp. Doesn't seem to take much to help as you can see. The MEC brass new-case crimp starter seems to work a bit better than the standard Hornady plastic pre-fold die. Considering how often this problem comes up with hulls from the high velocity factory shells, it's worth inspecting the hulls before loading and using the spare prefold die as needed to insure good crimps. Interestingly, the problem never seems to appear with the Winchester or Remington factory 1325'/s 24 gram bunker loads, only with the 1 1/8 oz (32 gram) 1300'/s high velocity loads.
Arrow points to the just barely visible nick in the case mouth caused by the wad's OP cup catching. Note the consequence to the wad. This was caught because of the operating handle resistance and an insertion sound that was just a tad not quite right. Doubtful this would normally be caught visually. Hull was likely tilted in the station, causing the wad guide fingers to mis-insert. If you have occasional, unexpected pookies, this may be one explanation.
Example of
hulls that may cause
wad insertion problems. These were
picked up off a field and were obviously somebody's bad-crimp rejects.
Curiously, once a hull has crimped bad, it seems much harder to fix and
rather than waste a lot of time attempting to fix the crimp before
loading,
it's better to
leave them lay. Reloading 410 bore NSSA skeet shotshells. Reloading
410: does it
make sense? New, highly
reloadable, Winchester or Remington 410 shells cost around $90
– $110
per case
of 250. Reloading those cases costs in the neighborhood
of $35 - $40 a
case.
Quite a savings. If you do any significant amount of 410 skeet
(or sporting clay) shooting, it makes economic sense to reload
them. Hulls: For hulls, the Winchester 410 seems to last the longest. . . Although the Remingtons, in a reversal of the 12 and 20 gauge experience, resize easier. As a factory shell, the Winchester also has the virtue of excellent consistency over the chronograph in the lots I've tested. 410 (and 28 ga) hulls tend to be hard to come by: they are rarely seen laying on the grounds. As always, the best way is to buy new factories, fire them in your gun, and reload them. Powder issues:
There are 7 (8? Alliant now lists 410 bore data for their 300-MP) powders usable for 410 reloading: Accurate's 4100, Alliant's 410 and 2400, Hodgdon's Lil' Gun and H110, IMR's 7225 and Winchester's 296. Good Old Timers Alliant (nee Hercules) 2400 and IMR 7225 (nee Dupont) are not often used with today's all plastic components because of pressure or bulking issues. They worked quite well with the nitro card/"felt" wad columns of yesteryear—especially 2400 in the paper cases of the time—and now work with only some very few current plastic component sets, judging by the few available manufacturer's recipes. So for all
the
usual
reasons
(availability, bushings, etc.) it essentially comes
down to these four: Alliant's 410, Hodgdon's Lil' Gun and
H110, plus Winchester's 296. These four could be boiled down further by
your
desired
velocities. If you want your shells to be 1250—1300 '/s,
then you'll
be using the more elastic H110 or 296 (these powders also certainly
quite work well at
1200'/s, just not as economical compared to the following two).
While Alliant's 410 and Hodgdon's Lil' Gun excel at the 1200'/s level;
the manufacturer's data sheets show that pressures run too hot
(are unsafe) at
higher velocities. Alliant's 410 is the most
economical to use (nearly 19 10-box cases can be loaded from a single
8# keg)
and has
the cleanest burn, with very little ash left
in the barrel. Both of these latter propellants are also pretty free of
powder leakage housekeeping issues at the loading bench. The Powder Bushings issue: Powder
bushings: This is one time that maybe it's wise to learn which 410
powder is
in most reliable inventory at your local sources and stick
with
it. Hornady
offers only five bushings for 410 powders. Unlike for bunker powders,
there are gaps between the bushing offerings, but the drops will be
pretty close to recipe specs. If
you want to zero in on the exact drops required, there are several
routes
available: tape or build up the walls of a larger bushing with nail
polish or the like, buy
the bushings that Ponsness-Warren
offers: 1A, 2A, 3A
and
1AX, 2AX, 3AX. Or buy the MEC
to Hornady bushing adapter available from Precision Reloading/Ballistic
Products, among
others and buy/use
MEC bushings. Since the machine vibration will likely be different,
you may want to buy more than just the one bushing specifically
suggesting the desired drop from the MEC chart. Changing to a different
manufacturer's
bushings sometimes works because of that difference in machine
vibration. For example, the Ponsness-Warren 2A bushing appears to drop
about three-tenths of a grain more Winchester 296 powder than Hornady's
#266
bushing:
that may hit the
exact recommended recipe drop specified in the recipe you're using,
avoiding the need to ream or file out a
Hornady #266 bushing to get the exact value. Wads: All
of the major wad suppliers offer one. And that's it. One. Each. Unlike
the
sometimes bewildering multiple offerings available for 12 gauge
reloading from a single manufacturer, as Claybuster or
Downrange. Occasionally it
seems that cases have a different volume after multiple reloadings, so
keeping a couple of wad flavors that still work with your basic recipe
might be worthwhile if you run into this.
Left: shot too high—almost to the rim—in the case. Too much shot or powder? Nope—see the right picture: it's due to the wad petals not lying against the shell walls, reducing the shot chamber capacity, usually because a shot pellet(s) lands perfectly to hold the petal(s) away from the case wall. Happens in 12 ga too, but the problem is more critical in the pee-wee 410 cases.
Examples of defective wad petal shapes that can create the "excess shot" problem shown above, left and center. Right, perfect petal alignment. Petals can be bent back into alignment. Seems like all brands can have this problem. Shot selection: Considering
that the cheaper soft shot deforms so easily—delivering more
open
patterns,
perhaps desirable in the 12, but something not so desirable in the
1/2 ounce 410 skeet load—the
only real choice for 410 reloading is high antimony magnum shot from
such suppliers as Remington, West Coast, et al. Not only will the
patterns be at their best, but the antimony hardener makes
each pellet lighter putting extra pellets in each pattern. Shot bushings: Hornady
offers two half-ounce shot
bushings. One for target, one for field loads with larger sized shot
(Be aware that shot larger than size 8 1/2 can jam together in
the
410 (and 28) shot
drop tube.
Visually checking the shot level in the case before advancing each
shell to the pre-fold station is a wise precaution and a strongly
recommended loading procedure/habit to have in this situation.).
The shot field
bushing drops a
bit more than 218 grains, 1/2 ounce shot drop with high-antimony #9
shot—about 227 grains.
The #9 skeet
bushing drops about 220 grains with high-antimony #9 shot.
Drops about 222 grains with shot using "other hardeners". Probably
drops
about 225 grains with chilled soft-lead
shot. Crimping Issues:
To start with, what they should look like using AAHS hulls: Left, perfect prefold and right, the result.
A few more examples of expectable (AAHS) crimps. Bottom left and center: Winchester AAHS factory shells. Top left and center, two perfect crimps. Upper right, flat to slightly convex crimp from insufficient prefold caused by a short case that was fixed with additional hand-applied prefold using a spare crimp die. Final crimper is set too short for the shorter case (Note the lack of crimp depth.). Lower right, a not un-typical crimp just about closed enough to keep the #9 shot in.
Left: Insufficient prefold. Needs to be folded down to about a 3 mm gap for reliable results. Insufficient prefold usually occurs when a shorter case is used than the prefold die is set for—as you would expect, 410 cases are no exception to the pre-fold set-for-length rule. Center and right, the result. The difference in case length is about 1 mm shorter—doesn't take much. Winchester HS 410 cases seem to vary about 0.04"/1 mm (63 mm +/- 1mm), enough to create the above problem unless sorted by length. Federal cases seem about 2.44"/62 mm, Cheddite 2.48"/63 mm and based on past 12 ga experience, plus actual Cheddite 410 case measurements, there will be virtually no length variance. Remington case length is about 2.52"/64 mm.
Remington crimp results with the 366. The two left shells are factories for reference. It is possible to close the crimp a bit
more to eliminate the center
holes, but the price can be a
bulge out at the crimp line that increases chambering difficulties
(maximum cartridge dimension is 0.462, per the 5th Edition Lyman
Reloading
Handbook, page 408).
The result then may be that shells
will then need to be pushed into the chamber rather than them just
going in
easily. An inconvenience in over-unders, could be a jam in pumps or
autoloaders. It's best to set the pre-fold to the point
just
before
the
case starts to
show a side bulge (the case line is still smooth). then use the
least amount of crimp depth possible to assure chambering
ease
and longer case life. A 28 Ga Note: Many of the above comments apply to 28 ga as well. Both require more time consuming attention to the process. For that reason—just like the big factory loader's experience where 10,000+ shells per hour production rate is often the norm in 12 ga, but 410 runs are about 2400 per hour—you may get a much slower production rate, perhaps as low as 150+ per hour as compared to the typical 400 shells per hour average comfortably achievable in 12 ga. However, the actual rate can easily be at the 400/hour rate: case mouth hull condition and wad petal alignment are the big factors in 410 reloading speed as well as your level of desired crimp perfection. Once-fired Remington's seem to be the fastest loading, easily matching the 400/hour (if oops free!) rate of 12 gauge. Special section: ver 1.8 End part III, 40 years with the Hornady 366. Link to Part I: Introduction Link
to Part II: General problem solutions Link
to Part III: On poor crimps, 410 reloading Link to Part IV: Changing gauges Link to Part V: Annual maintenance Link to Part VI: On buying a used 366 Thanx
to Chuck
Dietl
for reviewing and sharing his comments to make this series better. A
final note of appreciation and a big thanks to Hornady
for keeping
the
366 reloader in production and parts easily available! Last revision: 3/2012 |